Sound cards overrated?

Wouter · 11-02-2006, 01:47 PM

I'm in the process of selecting components for a new PC, and talking about it with my friend.

His opinion is that the audio on the motherboard sounds just as good as any soundcard out there. Then again, my ears seem more sensitive to music quality than most people.

Gaming audio and music listening are very important for me. I want to have clear and crisp sound. Surround sound is important too for games.

I am looking at a SB X-Fi Extreme music, in to be combined with 5.1 surround boxes or headphones.

So what do you think? Are they overrated? Would I benefit from such a card, or would you say 'just drop the card'?

Big B · 11-02-2006, 01:32 PM

That depends on the person. For the casual user, the on-board sound is usually fine. Then you have the audiophiles that need a better sound solution than what's packaged. For me, the Dynamic Edge I have works just as well as a SoundBlaster Live! or Audigy, and I'm sure it'd be the same with the X-Fi. Now, Creative leans more toward gaming than other companies, so if you're not gaming, then you might want to look at products by M-Audio or Terratec.

max12590 · 12-02-2006, 04:27 AM

Buuuuut, the great thing about the Creative line is that they have excellent surround, which is a must for a gamer.

Calebcross · 12-02-2006, 06:12 AM

the best deal out right now imo is the Abit Fatality mobo with the fatality sound system included. the sound system itself cost $300, but if u get the board it is included for only $218.

I have always had creative products and have been happy with them. the x-fi is a great card and incredible for gaming. I also watch Dvds on my comp sometimes and the sound card with surround sound is awesome.

Creative ftw

megamaced · 12-02-2006, 12:46 PM

It is true that on-board sound is getting better. And the AC'97 is probably one of the better codecs. But you would hear the difference straight away with a dedicated sound card.

Merlin · 15-02-2006, 11:36 PM

I can recommend the Creative X-FI FPS Edition as a good soundcard. My old 5.1 Live! wasnt really up to the job of true 5.1, but the X-FI performs far better. Playing games like FEAR and BF2 was a new experience

Wouter · 16-02-2006, 07:42 AM

FPS? Don't think I've seen that model anywhere? I only know Xtreme Music, Platinum, Fatality and Elite Pro?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Merlin

I can recommend the Creative X-FI FPS Edition as a good soundcard. My old 5.1 Live! wasnt really up to the job of true 5.1, but the X-FI performs far better. Playing games like FEAR and BF2 was a new experience

Merlin · 16-02-2006, 08:46 PM

Its Fatality FPS edition, forgot about the fatality bit.

Wouter · 16-02-2006, 10:43 PM

What does the Fatality have that the Xtreme Music doesn't have? I mean, in terms of sound quality.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Merlin

Its Fatality FPS edition, forgot about the fatality bit.

Exfoliate · 17-02-2006, 11:24 PM

The Fatality has 2MB's or XRAM or somthing like that, it doesn't do much yet, just think of it as getting a 512MB version of the 7800GTX to play Mathblaster 3d. (okay slight exageration). It's bascially there so future apps and games that require serious computation will have a little cache to work with to keep the audio pumping with all the bells and whistles maxed. That's how I see it anyway, someone else will have a better description I'm sure.

11-02-2006, 01:47 PM	#1 (permalink) Top
Wouter Big Geek Join Date: Feb 2006 Gender: Male Posts: 255 Times Helpful: 1 My Mood: Cheerful Status: Offline My Computer	Sound cards overrated? I'm in the process of selecting components for a new PC, and talking about it with my friend. His opinion is that the audio on the motherboard sounds just as good as any soundcard out there. Then again, my ears seem more sensitive to music quality than most people. Gaming audio and music listening are very important for me. I want to have clear and crisp sound. Surround sound is important too for games. I am looking at a SB X-Fi Extreme music, in to be combined with 5.1 surround boxes or headphones. So what do you think? Are they overrated? Would I benefit from such a card, or would you say 'just drop the card'? __________________

11-02-2006, 01:32 PM	#2 (permalink) Top
Big B HWF Godfather Join Date: Dec 2001 Age: 28 Male Posts: 9,636 Times Helpful: 585 My Mood: Devilish Status: Offline My Computer	That depends on the person. For the casual user, the on-board sound is usually fine. Then you have the audiophiles that need a better sound solution than what's packaged. For me, the Dynamic Edge I have works just as well as a SoundBlaster Live! or Audigy, and I'm sure it'd be the same with the X-Fi. Now, Creative leans more toward gaming than other companies, so if you're not gaming, then you might want to look at products by M-Audio or Terratec. __________________ Hardware Forums\|HWF Rules\|My DVD's\|PSU FAQ\|HWF Folding Team\|2CPU

12-02-2006, 04:27 AM	#3 (permalink) Top
max12590 Masterful Geek Join Date: Nov 2004 Age: 17 Male Posts: 1,016 Times Helpful: 76 Status: Offline My Computer	Buuuuut, the great thing about the Creative line is that they have excellent surround, which is a must for a gamer. __________________ In the words of a certain Battlefield 2 commander, "They're spawnin' like crazy at the Gas Station and then tryin' to Forrest Gump it down the Interstate."

12-02-2006, 12:46 PM	#5 (permalink) Top
megamaced Geek Geek Geek! Join Date: Nov 2005 Age: 24 Male Posts: 3,465 Times Helpful: 352 My Mood: Fine Status: Offline My Computer	It is true that on-board sound is getting better. And the AC'97 is probably one of the better codecs. But you would hear the difference straight away with a dedicated sound card. __________________ "A computer is like air conditioning: it becomes useless when you open windows". ~Linus Torvalds

15-02-2006, 11:36 PM	#6 (permalink) Top
Merlin Geek Join Date: Mar 2005 Age: 28 Male Posts: 98 Times Helpful: 8 My Mood: Drunk Status: Offline My Computer	I can recommend the Creative X-FI FPS Edition as a good soundcard. My old 5.1 Live! wasnt really up to the job of true 5.1, but the X-FI performs far better. Playing games like FEAR and BF2 was a new experience __________________

12-02-2006, 06:12 AM	#4 (permalink) Top
Calebcross Geek Trainee Join Date: Feb 2006 Gender: Male Posts: 19 Status: Offline My Computer	the best deal out right now imo is the Abit Fatality mobo with the fatality sound system included. the sound system itself cost $300, but if u get the board it is included for only $218. I have always had creative products and have been happy with them. the x-fi is a great card and incredible for gaming. I also watch Dvds on my comp sometimes and the sound card with surround sound is awesome. Creative ftw

16-02-2006, 08:46 PM	#8 (permalink) Top
Merlin Geek Join Date: Mar 2005 Age: 28 Male Posts: 98 Times Helpful: 8 My Mood: Drunk Status: Offline My Computer	Its Fatality FPS edition, forgot about the fatality bit. __________________

17-02-2006, 11:24 PM	#10 (permalink) Top
Exfoliate Captain Dial-up Join Date: Jan 2005 Age: 19 Male Posts: 4,258 Times Helpful: 223 Status: Offline My Computer	The Fatality has 2MB's or XRAM or somthing like that, it doesn't do much yet, just think of it as getting a 512MB version of the 7800GTX to play Mathblaster 3d. (okay slight exageration). It's bascially there so future apps and games that require serious computation will have a little cache to work with to keep the audio pumping with all the bells and whistles maxed. That's how I see it anyway, someone else will have a better description I'm sure. __________________

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Why sound cards?	harakim	Sound Cards and Speakers	13	04-01-2006 11:34 AM
Old Yamaha sound cards....	megamaced	Sound Cards and Speakers	4	20-12-2005 10:05 AM
Help Needed Regarding C-media Sound Cards	cliffyboro	Sound Cards and Speakers	9	14-03-2005 01:37 AM
Sound Cards	epson	Drivers and Firmware	3	07-01-2005 12:51 AM
Sound Cards?	Pircan	Sound Cards and Speakers	13	05-05-2003 02:21 PM