Hmmm… I would just uninstall the old drivers first regardless.
Whenever I have upgraded the drivers on my current ATI card, I have always uninstalled the older version of drivers. Moreover, the instructions from ATI have always specifically and clearly stated to do just that: 1. uninstall old drivers completely first, 2. then install new ones.
It seems totally unreasonable to me why there should be any exception to this when you upgrade to a new card (of the same brand). You’ll be getting new drivers for it, so I believe the same rules apply.
Now, I only have this experience with my ATI card; I have been using it forever and have never owned an nvidia card, actually. But I don’t see why nvidia cards would act much differently.
Most importantly, there is absolutely no downside to uninstalling video card drivers. None. So you will always be safe by doing that and then installing the new drivers once you get the new card plugged in. On the flip side, experimenting with whether you can get away with simply installing new drivers over the old ones might give you issues… Like I said, ATI, at least, always says to uninstall old drivers first. Thus, if I were to do this, it would make me feel much better to uninstall old drivers first, because then I have no fear of things somehow getting corrupted or whatever.
So my verdict is, just uninstall the old drivers regardless, and then put in new card, and then power up Windows, and then install new drivers.
Lay your doubts to rest. Yes, you will be able to load windows just fine without any drivers. In fact, it will probably look identical to how it looks under ideal conditions (with drivers), not because of anything the card contains, but because WinXP already has its own drivers for basic functionality (unless you’re dealing with win9x, then it will load up with very small resolution and only 16 colors, I think). It will only make a difference once you try to play games or watch a movie or something.
Sorry about the long-winded post. lol